Guide
If you run leadership development programs or executive coaching engagements, you need a way to measure whether they worked. There are dozens of survey and evaluation tools out there, but most weren't built for this purpose. We reviewed six that L&D consultancies actually use, compared them honestly, and laid out which one makes sense for different situations.
Full disclosure: ImpactCheck is our tool. We've included it in this roundup and tried to be straightforward about what it does and doesn't do.
Not every survey tool is a good evaluation tool. Before we get into specific products, here are the criteria that actually matter when you're measuring program impact for clients.
Most survey tools handle Level 1 (reaction) fine. The real question is whether the tool helps you measure Level 2 (learning) and Level 3 (behavior change). That usually means some form of before-and-after measurement, not just a satisfaction score. If your tool only asks "how satisfied were you?", you're stuck at Level 1. Learn how retrospective surveys measure change.
When a survey goes out to your client's leadership team, it represents your consultancy. Generic tool branding undermines the professional image you've worked to build. Look for tools that let you add your logo, colors, and custom domains -- or at minimum, remove the vendor's own branding.
The ability to capture a "before" and "after" rating in a single survey -- often called a retrospective pre-test or post-then-pre design -- is what separates evaluation tools from form builders. Without it, you're measuring opinions, not change.
Your response rate depends on how easy the survey is to complete. Mobile-friendly design, minimal friction, no account creation required, and fast load times all matter. If participants have to create a login or wrestle with a clunky interface, you'll lose them.
You'll need to share results with clients. The question is whether the tool gives you something presentable -- branded PDFs, clear charts, shift scores -- or whether you'll be copying numbers into a slide deck every time.
Evaluation is a cost center for most consultancies. The tool needs to be good enough to justify its cost, and for many small and mid-size firms, "free" isn't just nice -- it's a requirement. Watch out for tools that gate essential features behind expensive tiers.
Six tools that L&D consultancies commonly use for post-program and post-coaching evaluation, in no particular order of ranking. We've tried to be fair about all of them, including our own.
Purpose-built micro-survey tool for L&D consultancies.
Best for: Consultancies that need branded, anonymous evaluation surveys at no cost.
Pricing: Free.
The most widely used general-purpose online survey platform.
Best for: Teams that need a versatile survey tool with advanced logic and integrations.
Pricing: Free tier (limited); paid plans from $25/month.
Free form builder included with Google Workspace.
Best for: Internal surveys and quick feedback collection where branding doesn't matter.
Pricing: Free.
Design-forward survey tool known for its one-question-at-a-time format.
Best for: Organizations that prioritize respondent experience and visual design.
Pricing: Free tier (very limited); paid plans from $25/month.
Enterprise experience management platform used by large organizations and universities.
Best for: Large enterprise L&D teams with complex evaluation needs and budget to match.
Pricing: Custom (typically $1,500+/year; contact for quote).
L&D-specific evaluation platform built around the Kirkpatrick model, now part of Explorance.
Best for: Enterprise L&D departments that need benchmarking data and Kirkpatrick-aligned evaluation.
Pricing: Custom enterprise pricing (contact for quote).
How all six tools compare across the features that matter most for L&D evaluation.
| ImpactCheck | SurveyMonkey | Google Forms | Typeform | Qualtrics | Metrics That Matter | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | $25+/mo | Free | $25+/mo | $$$$ | $$$$ |
| White-label surveys | Paid | Paid | ||||
| Before/after measurement | ||||||
| L&D evaluation templates | ||||||
| Facilitator tracking | ||||||
| Branded PDF reports | Paid | |||||
| Respondent anonymity |
There's no single "best" tool. It depends on what you need, who you are, and what you're willing to spend. Here's our honest take.
You just need something free and fast, and you don't care about branding. For internal feedback, quick polls, or situations where the survey doesn't need to represent your consultancy, Google Forms is hard to beat. It works, it's free, and everyone knows how to use it. See our full Google Forms comparison.
You need a versatile survey tool with complex logic, integrations, and don't mind paying for branding and export features. SurveyMonkey does a lot of things well, and if you use surveys across multiple parts of your business (not just L&D evaluation), the breadth is worth paying for. See our full SurveyMonkey comparison.
You're an enterprise L&D department with budget, complex research needs, and a team to manage the platform. Qualtrics gives you research-grade capabilities. Metrics That Matter gives you L&D-specific evaluation with industry benchmarks. Both are serious tools at serious price points.
You're a leadership development consultancy that needs branded, purpose-built evaluation surveys at no cost. You want your logo on the survey and the report. You want before-and-after measurement that quantifies the impact of your programs. You want to track results by facilitator. And you want it set up in minutes, not weeks. That's exactly what we built ImpactCheck to do. Browse our templates to see what it looks like.
Pick a template, add your branding, and send your first evaluation survey in minutes. No credit card, no trial period, no catch.
Create your free accountFree to use. No credit card required.